Pirates! The Penzance Musical

In 1983, Gilbert and Sullivan’s “Pirates of Penzance” was made into a movie.  The movie starred most of the people who had recently starred in the Broadway revival.  Kevin Kline was the pirate king, Linda Ronstadt was Mabel Stanley, and Rex Smith was Frederic.  Angela Lansbury was Ruth in the movie, but did not play her on Broadway.  Although I had seen the show several times, I loved that movie.  We bought it on VHS and watched it at least once a year until we got rid of our VHS player.  At which point we bought the movie on DVD.  I know all the songs by heart.

For my birthday this year, John and Jackie bought tickets for all of us to see “Pirates! The Penzance Musical.”  None of us were sure how it would be the same or different from the Gilbert and Sullivan version, but it sounded like a fun take on something that we had seen multiple times and loved every time.  Jackie is the only one who was not familiar with Gilbert and Sullivan or the “Pirates of Penzance.”

Here is the description of the musical:  “Pirates! The Penzance Musical” fuses the wit and wordplay of Gilbert & Sullivan with Caribbean rhythms and French Quarter flair for an outrageously clever romp. Raised by pirates, Frederic believes his 21st birthday will finally set him free, until a twist of fate complicates everything. When he falls for Mabel, the spirited daughter of Major-General Stanley, pirates, policemen, and villagers collide in a whirlwind of swordplay, mistaken identities, and fast-flying patter. Led by a tongue-twisting Major General, a swaggering Pirate King, and a shipload of unforgettable musical numbers, this high-energy adventure overflows with romance, mischief, and off-the-charts fun, perfect for first-timers and Gilbert & Sullivan aficionados alike.

“Pirates!” debuted on Broadway in April 2025 with David Hyde Pierce as Major General Stanley.  This production in Columbus was the first performance post-Broadway.  The performance was a collaboration between The Columbus Association for the Performing Arts (CAPA) and Opera Columbus.  The three performances were staged at the Palace Theatre, which is celebrating its 100th anniversary this year.

 

From the very first moment to the last rousing note, “Pirates! The Penzance Musical” was sheer joy.  I can’t remember ever enjoying a performance so much.  All the familiar and beloved characters were there.  The plot was essentially the same and most of the music was familiar.  The words were different in some places, but it didn’t detract from my enjoyment of the show.  The ending changed, because you can’t be errant members of the aristocracy if you are in New Orleans.  But the ending has always been the weakest plot point of a moderately absurd story.

All the wit and satiric fun of Gilbert and Sullivan came through in “Pirates! The Penzance Musical.”  Frederic’s absurd devotion to duty.  The Pirate King not realizing that people might be lying to him about being orphans.  Frederic’s birthday on February 29.  Mabel pledging to wait 68 years for her true love.  So silly and so much fun!

In addition to the wonderful score, the cast was stellar.  The Pirate King had a lovely, smooth baritone voice.  Nina West, a famous Columbus drag queen, played Ruth in the best campy style.  Frederic and Mabel were earnest.  I especially enjoyed the Stanley sisters, who were a little more enlightened and martial than in the traditional musical.  Because the singers were from Columbus, the theater was full of friends and family.  There was a wonderful, synergistic energy between the audience and the cast.  Many people in the audience dressed up like pirates.

I really enjoyed this particular birthday present.  I’m sure I will remember it as one of the best ever.  If you ever get a chance, I encourage you to go see “Pirates! The Penzance Musical.”  It is a rollicking good time!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *